After the Indonesia national team failed to reach the AFF 2026 semifinals, head coach John Herdman’s future became a topic of discussion.
Kurniawan Dwi Yulianto said the evaluation of the coach and contractual matters should be viewed as separate procedures.
Even as criticism and calls for a replacement continue, no actual decision has already been made.
3-line summary
1. Kurniawan referred to the coach evaluation process
2. Indonesia finished third in the AFF group stage
3. It remains to be seen whether a coaching change will be a PSSI decision
AFF 2026 Ends at 7 Points
The starting point of this discussion is the Indonesia national team’s group-stage elimination. According to reports by VIVA.co.id and ANTARA News, the national team finished third in Group A with 7 points, failing to advance to the semifinals. Singapore was second with 8 points, while Vietnam finished first in the group with 10 points.
The decisive results are also clear. Indonesia lost 0-3 to Vietnam at Cibinong Pakansari Stadium on August 3, and the final match, held at Jalan Besar Stadium in Singapore on August 7, ended in a 1-1 draw. Taking only one point from the final match led to the gap in the standings.
The fact that this search term drew interest in the Indonesian search market does not indicate the match location or the location of the media outlet. Locations should be distinguished only within the scope established by individual evidence, such as stadiums and event venues confirmed in reports.
“An Evaluation Is Necessary, but the Decision Belongs to the Federation”
In podcast remarks, Kurniawan said that after every tournament, there should be a report from and an evaluation of the coach. Whether the results are good or poor, an evaluation should follow, and PSSI is responsible for that evaluation.
The point is not to pretend that poor results did not happen. Rather, it is that evaluation and a confirmed dismissal should not be treated as the same thing. Criticism of the coach may be raised, but the contract and future status must go through established procedures.
He also said that if PSSI actually decides to replace the coach, it should proceed in a manner consistent with the contract terms. Therefore, what is currently confirmed is the need for an evaluation and his personal opinion—not an announcement that Herdman has been dismissed or that a successor has been appointed.
Talk of a Replacement Remains at the Proposal and Demand Stage
Andre Rosiade, chairman of Semen Padang, criticized Herdman’s performance. He assessed that the national-team players’ fitness appeared to have declined compared with the previous coach’s tenure, and also said the team must win the upcoming tournament. This should be understood as Andre’s observation and demand.
In a Suara.com report, Andre mentioned Nil Maizar as a possible replacement if the target is not achieved at the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026. However, based on the wording of the report, this was a joking suggestion, not presented as an official PSSI personnel decision. The mention of a candidate’s name does not immediately mean that a coaching change has been confirmed.
The points to watch going forward are clear: an official PSSI decision, a contract-related announcement involving Herdman, and the results the national team produces at the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026, scheduled from September 24 to October 4. Especially when there is much discussion, it is most important to distinguish critical remarks from actual administrative decisions.
Standards for Reading the Next Announcement
It is difficult to reach a conclusion about news related to kurniawan dwi yulianto based on a single number or sentence. The meaning becomes clearer when you distinguish who made the announcement, whether the statement concerns an already implemented fact or a future plan, and whether the target and timing are specified.
Even within the same material, explanations of necessity, discussions, implementation plans, and actual implementation can be different stages. Even if an announcement appears large in scope, it is necessary to check together what it applies to and what procedures remain, so as not to overstate or understate the current situation.
In subsequent news, compare whether a new announcement repeats existing information or whether the subject, schedule, or implementation status has actually changed. Reviewing the related reports below can also help identify differences in wording that may be easy to miss from the headline alone.
References
Tags #KurniawanDwiYulianto #KurniawanDwiYulianto #JohnHerdman #JohnHerdman #IndonesianFootball #IndonesiaNationalTeam #AFF2026 #ASEANCup #FIFAASEANCup #PSSI #NilMaizar #SemenPadang #SingaporeMatch